Family of four taking a selfie at the Seven Mile Bridge in the Florida Keys

Florida Keys With Kids: Where We Stayed on Points and What It Really Cost

We live in Florida, so the Keys are our easy road trip. We’ve been to Key West three times now with the boys: a South Florida road trip in March 2025, two nights at the Perry Hotel in July 2025, and a week in Key West, Marathon and Islamorada in April 2026.

The Keys are not cheap. Hotels can easily run $400 to $800 a night. But between free night certificates, hotel points and a few card credits, we’ve stayed at some of the nicest places in the Keys for very little cash.

Here’s every hotel we stayed in, what it would have cost, what we actually paid, and the stops worth making along the way.

The numbers at a glance

TripHotelsCash valueWhat we paid
March 2025 road trip, Keys onlyCourtyard Key Largo, Courtyard Key West Waterfront, Three Waters Resort$1,498$66.38
April 2026Perry Hotel Key West, Isla Bella Beach Resort, Three Waters Resort$2,160$349.13

Where we stayed in the Florida Keys

Key Largo: Courtyard by Marriott Key Largo

On our first trip we drove down to Key Largo and stayed at the Courtyard, using a 50K Marriott free night certificate plus 4,000 points. The room would have cost $280. We paid nothing.

We arrived in the late evening, which made it the perfect first stop. It breaks up the drive, and you wake up already in the Keys.

Room with two queen beds at the Courtyard by Marriott Key Largo
Our room at the Courtyard Key Largo

Key West, option 1: Courtyard Key West Waterfront

For our one night in Key West in March 2025, we used another 50K free night certificate plus 12,000 Marriott points to cover a $508 stay.

We also used a suite night award, and it got us a two-bedroom suite: three queen beds in one room, a king in the other, two full bathrooms and a living room. For a family of four, that’s hard to beat.

The hotel sits on the water with mangroves nearby. The boys spent time exploring them and spotted baby sharks, horseshoe crabs and geckos.

Key West, option 2: The Perry Hotel

We’ve stayed at the Perry Hotel Key West twice, in July 2025 and again in April 2026, both times booked through Chase’s The Edit with our Sapphire Reserve. Both stays came with breakfast and a $100 property credit, and we used the credit for dinner. The Perry also has shuffleboard, which the boys always enjoy.

Our first stay came out close to free with the $250 Edit credit. The second was quite a bit more expensive: we used 25,000 Chase points plus the $250 credit on a stay that would have cost $888, and we paid $138. That one also came with early check-in and a 4pm checkout.

Our honest take: it’s a decent hotel in a decent location, but it’s not our favorite. We’ve booked it because it worked out well enough with The Edit, but we liked the Courtyard Key West Waterfront better. Next time, we’d probably try a different hotel on points instead.

Marathon: Isla Bella Beach Resort

Isla Bella was a great stay, and we’d go back in a heartbeat. It’s a five-star beachfront resort in Marathon, and we booked it through Amex Fine Hotels + Resorts. The $300 FHR credit brought a $438 stay down to $138. FHR also included breakfast for two, a $100 property credit, noon check-in and a 4pm checkout. We used the $100 credit to buy lunch at their store.

Our room was fantastic: a two-bedroom, oceanfront, with a beautiful view. The whole property is peaceful and really nice, and we’d honestly love to go back.

Islamorada: Three Waters Resort & Marina (twice)

Three Waters is the one place we’ve stayed on both trips, and that says a lot.

2025: We used an 85K Marriott free night certificate from our Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant Amex. The standard room was $710, and we applied a suite upgrade, which put us in an oceanfront suite worth about $1,200. We paid only the $66.38 resort fee.

April 2026: We came back with another 85K free night certificate plus 13,500 points. The stay would have cost $834, and we paid $73.13. We didn’t get a suite this time, but we had the same perks otherwise.

Two smiling boys on the beach at Three Waters Resort in Islamorada
Back at Three Waters in April 2026

Why we keep coming back:

  • Fish Like a Local. This free fishing program is the main reason we keep going back. Our boys are obsessed with it, and Patrick, who runs it, is amazing.
  • Oceanfront suite with a private balcony on our first stay. Waking up to that view was unreal.
  • Free water activities. We kayaked, paddleboarded and rode bikes around the resort.
  • A private beach and dock, perfect for the boys to explore.
  • The pool, which we could have spent all day at.
  • A $60 dining credit on our first stay, and breakfast was top-notch: tropical fruit, fresh pastries and eggs benedict.

Can’t decide between Isla Bella and Three Waters? The boys compared both:

Our favorite stops with kids

The boys made a video of our Keys road trip, including Robbie’s and Keys Cable Park:

Robbie’s Tarpon Feeding, Islamorada. This was our favorite stop on the first trip. You buy a bucket of fish and hand-feed huge tarpon as they leap out of the water, sometimes right at your fingertips. Watch out for the pelicans. One stole a fish right out of one of the boys’ hands. There are also shops, waterfront dining and great views on the dock. We had to keep moving to make it to Key West, but we could have stayed longer.

Tacos Jalisco food truck. Hands down some of the best tacos we’ve had. If you’re ever in the Keys, run, don’t walk. We went back on our 2026 trip too. Tacos Jalisco is honestly a huge reason we keep going back to the Keys, and we’re already itching for another taco run.

The 7 Mile Bridge. Turquoise water on both sides. It feels like driving through paradise. There’s a spot to stop and walk at one end, and it’s great for drone shots.

Porky’s Bayside. A casual spot right on the water with fresh seafood and BBQ sandwiches. Laid back and quirky, which is the theme of the whole Keys.

Shell World. A fun stop for souvenirs and quirky finds. We didn’t buy anything, since we collect memories more than things, but it’s a good place to soak in the Keys vibe.

Keys Cable Park. The boys took on an obstacle course over the water. It was a bit grimy with algae, but they had a blast being the only ones there.

Two boys in life jackets at Keys Cable Park in Marathon
Ready for Keys Cable Park

Mallory Square at sunset, Key West. Beautiful, but crowded. Get there early if you want a good spot. We arrived just a few minutes before sunset and still found a platform behind some fencing with a perfect view, so if you’re late, don’t give up. There were street performers and vendors too.

Sailboats at sunset from Mallory Square in Key West
Sunset at Mallory Square

The Southernmost Point. The classic Key West photo. We didn’t feel like waiting in the line, so we took a photo with a different landmark instead.

Duval Street and Fogarty’s. We had dinner at Fogarty’s, known for its frozen drinks. I can 100% recommend the Miami Vice. After dinner, we walked Duval Street and took in the atmosphere.

Frozen drinks at Fogarty's and Flying Monkeys Saloon on Duval Street in Key West
Frozen drinks at Fogarty's

The best key lime pie in Key West (according to locals)

On our 2026 trip, the boys asked Key West locals where to find the best key lime pie, then did a blind taste test of the six places the locals named: Red Shoe, A&B Lobster House, Blue Heaven, Kermit’s, La Concha and Key West Cooking Show.

So which one won? Watch the video to find out!

Here’s the full taste test:

Brother Battle: a Key West scavenger hunt

The boys filmed a second video in Key West. I built a five-clue scavenger hunt across town, and they raced each other to solve it. The clues sent them all over Key West, from a green shop on Duval Street to the home of a writer who kept cats with extra toes. Only one brother could win, and one of them got lost along the way.

If you’re visiting Key West with kids, a DIY scavenger hunt is a great way to see the town and keep everyone moving.

Watch who won:

How to book the Keys on points

  • Use Marriott free night certificates. Three of our Keys stays were Marriott, and certificates from cards like the Bonvoy Brilliant cover most of the bill. Topping a certificate up with a few thousand points lets you book pricier nights.
  • Use card hotel credits on luxury stays. Amex Fine Hotels + Resorts and Chase’s The Edit turned two expensive Keys resorts into $138 nights, with breakfast and property credits included.
  • Know that the Keys are a tough redemption. There are other points hotels in Key West, including the Hyatt Centric Key West (Category 8, currently 35,000 to 55,000 points a night), three Hyatt Vacation Club properties in that same range, a Hampton Inn at about 52,000 Hilton points, and a Fairfield by Marriott and La Concha, though those two usually ask for too many points to be worth it. Honestly, the Keys aren’t an easy place to get a good redemption. Whether any of these makes sense depends 100% on availability and how many points they’re asking for on your dates.
  • Watch the resort fees. Free night certificates don’t always cover resort fees. At Three Waters, that’s what we paid both times.
  • Book early. The Keys are popular, especially in winter and spring, and award space at the best properties goes fast.

Work with us

Want help planning your Keys trip?

Figuring out which certificates, credits and points to use where is exactly what we do in our Points Strategy.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top