Two travelers smiling and toasting with sparkling wine on an Aer Lingus flight

Points or Cash? How We Actually Decide

There’s a rule you’ll hear from almost everyone in points and miles: use points for business class and expensive fares, and pay cash for cheap economy. It’s a good rule. It’s mostly our rule too.

But I break it sometimes, on purpose. This month alone I made one redemption I wasn’t happy about, cancelled another one within a day, and booked two that were easy calls. Here’s how I actually decide, with the real numbers from each.

Kelly smiling in an Etihad business class seat by the window
Etihad business out of Kuala Lumpur, booked with 49,500 JetBlue points.

The short answer

Use points for business class and expensive fares. Pay cash for cheap economy when cash allows. And when cash doesn’t allow, a low-value redemption can still be the right call.

That last part is the one most points content leaves out.

What “cents per point” tells you, and what it doesn’t

Cents per point is the standard way to judge a redemption. You take the cash price of the ticket, subtract the taxes and fees you still pay on the award, and divide by the points you used. Under 1 cent is usually not a great use of points.

It’s a useful number, but it only answers one question: was this a good use of points? It doesn’t tell you whether saving the cash mattered more that week. And for business class, it’s measured against a cash price most families would never pay, which is why we don’t lean on retail value as the headline.

So here are the questions I actually ask.

1. Is this what points are for?

Sometimes the answer is obvious. Later this month I’m flying Cathay Pacific business class from Shanghai to Kuala Lumpur through Hong Kong for 27,000 Asia Miles plus $160. That’s about 2.6 cents a point. Then Etihad business from Kuala Lumpur to Doha through Abu Dhabi, for 49,500 JetBlue points, about 6.7 cents a point.

Those are easy yeses. Business class on points at a fraction of the cash price is exactly what the points are for.

That Etihad flight wasn’t my original plan. I’d booked Oman Air business through Muscat for 40,000 American AAdvantage miles plus $67.85, about 4 cents a point. Then, 12 days out, the Muscat to Doha leg was changed to economy. I wasn’t OK paying business-class miles for an economy seat, so I cancelled the award and got all 40,000 miles back.

Then I went to seats.aero and searched for something better. Etihad business through Abu Dhabi was available with JetBlue points: 49,500 points, with the $71.85 in taxes paid from JetBlue travel credit. That’s 9,500 more points, but they’re points I have plenty of, my 40,000 AA miles are still in the bank, and the value went up to about 6.7 cents a point. I also get a lie-flat seat instead of a recliner. The trade-off is a longer day, with almost 8 hours in Abu Dhabi.

The lesson: if a partner award gets downgraded, cancel for your miles back and search for a better option before you settle for a worse seat.

2. How much cash does it save, and does that matter right now?

Delhi to Hanoi was a different story. An Air India economy seat for 25,000 Aeroplan points plus CAD $70.40 in taxes. With the seat I paid for, that came to about US$66 out of pocket. The cash fare was about US$280, so that’s roughly 0.9 cents a point. By the usual rule, I should have paid cash.

Aeroplan purchase summary showing 25,000 points plus CAD $70.40 in taxes for Delhi to Hanoi
The Delhi to Hanoi award: 25,000 Aeroplan points plus CAD $70.40.

I used the points anyway. It kept $214 in my pocket in the middle of a long trip. I’m not happy about the value, but I needed the cash more than I needed the points.

That’s the part the rule misses. Points are only worth something if they let you take the trip. If paying cash means stretching a budget that’s already tight, a low-value redemption can still be the right one.

3. Can you live with doing it twice in a row?

The very next leg, Hanoi to Shanghai, priced out about the same. I booked it with Aeroplan too, for 15,000 points plus CAD $77.30, and then I stopped. I couldn’t do two flights back to back at such terrible value.

So I cancelled the award within 24 hours, got all 15,000 points and the taxes back, and paid $152.10 cash for the same route on Air China. One low-value redemption to protect my cash was fine. Two in a row was wasting points I’d rather use for something like that Cathay flight.

Air Canada cancellation confirmation refunding 15,000 Aeroplan points plus CAD $77.30
Cancelled within 24 hours. All 15,000 points and the taxes came back.
Air China price details showing a total of 152.10 USD for Hanoi to Shanghai
The same route on Air China: $152.10 cash.

If you’re unsure about a booking, check the cancellation rules before you book. Being able to undo it quickly gave me room to change my mind.

4. Would you do it again?

Not every low-value redemption has a good reason behind it. On our 52-day trip this summer, we spent 32,000 Aeroplan points plus $198 in taxes on a 90-minute flight from Melbourne to Sydney that cost around $400 in cash. That’s about 0.6 cents a point, and I can’t point to a good reason for it.

I don’t really know what I was thinking. It’s the one we got wrong, and it’s in our full trip breakdown next to the ones we got right.

How we decide, in one line

  • Business class or an expensive fare: use points.
  • Cheap economy, and the cash is fine: pay cash and save the points.
  • Cheap economy, and you need the cash: using points is okay. Just don’t make it a habit.
  • Not sure: book something you can cancel, and give yourself a day.

Want help deciding?

If you’re new to points, start with our free Points Starter Guide. It covers the basics in plain English, including which cards we’d start with.

If you already have points and a trip in mind, that’s what Points Planning is for. We’ll look at your points and your route and help you decide where to use them and where to pay cash.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top